19.07.2013 Views

“PILICA FARM”, (IT-96-22) DRAŽEN ERDEMOVIĆ - Legislationline

“PILICA FARM”, (IT-96-22) DRAŽEN ERDEMOVIĆ - Legislationline

“PILICA FARM”, (IT-96-22) DRAŽEN ERDEMOVIĆ - Legislationline

SHOW MORE
SHOW LESS

Create successful ePaper yourself

Turn your PDF publications into a flip-book with our unique Google optimized e-Paper software.

DRAGOLJUB KUNARAC<br />

NOT AN OFFICIAL DOCUMENT<br />

C A S E I N F O R M A T I O N S H E E T<br />

“FOČA” (<strong>IT</strong>-<strong>96</strong>-23 and 23/1)<br />

Crimes convicted of (examples):<br />

KUNARAC, KOVAČ<br />

& VUKOVIĆ<br />

1<br />

Convicted of torture, rape and enslavement<br />

During the relevant period, leader of a reconnaissance unit of the Bosnian Serb Army<br />

(VRS) which formed part of the local Foča Tactical Group<br />

- Sentenced to 28 years’ imprisonment<br />

Torture and rape (crimes against humanity and violations of the laws or customs of war)<br />

• Dragoljub Kunarac raped three victims at his headquarters at Osmana Đikića Street no. 16 in Foča.<br />

• He aided and abetted the gang-rape of four victims by several of his soldiers.<br />

• He forced a victim to have sexual intercourse with him despite knowing that she did not consent.<br />

• He threatened to kill a witness and her son while trying to obtain information or a confession, along<br />

with two other soldiers in mid-July 1992.<br />

Enslavement (crimes against humanity)<br />

• Dragoljub Kunarac personally committed the act of enslavement by depriving two women of any control<br />

over their lives and treating them as property.<br />

RADOMIR KOVAČ Convicted of enslavement, rape and outrages upon personal dignity<br />

Crimes convicted of (examples):<br />

Enslavement (crimes against humanity)<br />

One of the sub-commanders of the military police of the Bosnian Serb Army (VRS)<br />

and a paramilitary leader in the town of Foča<br />

- Sentenced to 20 years’ imprisonment<br />

• Radomir Kovač detained two victims in his apartment for a period of about four months.<br />

• Imprisoning the girls and exercising his de facto power of ownership, Kovač intended to treat the four<br />

victims as his property.<br />

Rape (crimes against humanity and violations of the laws or customs of war)<br />

• He raped two victims along with other soldiers.<br />

• He raped two victims along with other soldiers during the period that they were kept in his apartment.<br />

• He had sexual intercourse with three victims despite knowing that they did not consent.


CASE INFORMATION SHEET “FOČA” (<strong>IT</strong>-<strong>96</strong>-23 and 23/1) KUNARAC, KOVAČ & VUKOVIĆ<br />

• He assisted other soldiers to rape three victims.<br />

Outrages upon personal dignity (violation of the laws or customs of war)<br />

• Radomir Kovač constantly humiliated and degraded four victims.<br />

• He forced three victims to dance naked on a table while he watched them.<br />

• He sold a victim to a man called “Dragec” for 200 German Marks and handed over another<br />

victim to his soldiers.<br />

• He sold two victims for 500 German Marks, each, to some Montenegrin soldiers.<br />

ZORAN VUKOVIĆ Convicted of torture, rape and enslavement<br />

Crimes convicted of (examples):<br />

One of the sub-commanders of the military police of the Bosnian Serb Army (VRS)<br />

and a member of the paramilitary in the town of Foča<br />

- Sentenced to 12 years’ imprisonment<br />

Torture and rape (crimes against humanity and violations of the laws or customs of war)<br />

• Zoran Vuković took, along with another soldier, a victim from the Partizan Sports Hall, Foča, to an<br />

apartment nearby and raped her despite knowing that she was only 15 years old and had not consented<br />

to having sexual intercourse with him.<br />

DRAGOLJUB KUNARAC<br />

Born 15 May 1<strong>96</strong>0 in Foča, Bosnia and Herzegovina<br />

Indictment 26 June 19<strong>96</strong>; first amended: 19 August 1998; second amended: 3<br />

September 1999; third amended: 1 December 1999<br />

Surrendered 4 March 1998<br />

Transferred to ICTY 5 March 1998<br />

Initial and further<br />

appearances<br />

9, 10 and 13 March 1998: on 9 March 1998 pleaded guilty to count 41 and<br />

not guilty to all other counts, on 13 March 1998 withdrew his guilty plea;<br />

28 August 1998, pleaded not guilty to all charges<br />

Judgement <strong>22</strong> February 2001, sentenced to 28 years' imprisonment<br />

Appeals Chamber judgement 12 June 2002, sentence of 28 years' imprisonment affirmed<br />

Serving sentence 12 December 2002, transferred to Germany to serve the remainder of his<br />

sentence; credit was given for time served since 4 March 1998<br />

RADOMIR KOVAČ<br />

Born 31 March 1<strong>96</strong>1 in Foča, Bosnia and Herzegovina<br />

Indictment 26 June 19<strong>96</strong>; second amended: 3 September 1999; third amended: 1<br />

December 1999<br />

Arrested 2 August 1999, by the multinational Stabilisation Force (SFOR)<br />

Transferred to ICTY 2 August 1999<br />

Initial and further appearances 4 August 1999, 24 September 1999, pleaded not guilty to all charges<br />

Judgement <strong>22</strong> February 2001, sentenced to 20 years' imprisonment<br />

Appeals Chamber judgement 12 June 2002, sentence of 20 years' imprisonment affirmed<br />

Serving sentence 28 November 2002, transferred to Norway to serve the remainder of<br />

his sentence; credit was given for time served since 2 August 1999<br />

2


CASE INFORMATION SHEET “FOČA” (<strong>IT</strong>-<strong>96</strong>-23 and 23/1) KUNARAC, KOVAČ & VUKOVIĆ<br />

ZORAN VUKOVIĆ<br />

Born 6 September 1955 in Brusna, Foča, Bosnia and Herzegovina<br />

Indictment 26 June 19<strong>96</strong>; redacted: 16 February 2000<br />

Arrested 23 December 1999, by SFOR<br />

Transferred to ICTY 24 December 1999<br />

Initial appearance 29 December 1999, pleaded not guilty on all counts<br />

Judgement <strong>22</strong> February 2001, sentenced to 12 years' imprisonment<br />

Appeals Chamber judgement 12 June 2002, sentence of 12 years' imprisonment affirmed<br />

Serving sentence 28 November 2002, transferred to Norway to serve the remainder of his<br />

sentence; credit was given for time served since 23 December 1999<br />

3


CASE INFORMATION SHEET “FOČA” (<strong>IT</strong>-<strong>96</strong>-23 and 23/1) KUNARAC, KOVAČ & VUKOVIĆ<br />

STATISTICS<br />

Trial days 58<br />

Witnesses called by Prosecution 33<br />

Witnesses called by Defence 29<br />

Prosecution exhibits 132<br />

Defence exhibits 130<br />

TRIAL<br />

Commenced 20 March 2000<br />

Closing arguments 20 – <strong>22</strong> November 2000<br />

Trial Chamber II Judge Florence Mumba (presiding), Judge David Hunt, Judge Fausto<br />

Pocar<br />

Counsel for the Prosecution Dirk Ryneveld, Hildegard Uertz-Retzlaff, Peggy Kuo, Daryl Mundis<br />

Counsel for the Defence For Dragoljub Kunarac: Slaviša Prodanović and Mara Pilipović<br />

For Radomir Kovač: Momir Kolesar and Vladimir Rajić<br />

For Zoran Vuković: Goran Jovanović and Jelena Lopičić<br />

APPEALS<br />

Appeals Chamber Judge Claude Jorda (presiding), Judge Mohamed Shahabuddeen, Judge<br />

Wolfgang Schomburg, Judge Mehmet Güney, Judge Theodor Meron<br />

Counsel for the Prosecution Anthony Carmona, Norul Rashid, Susan Lamb, Helen Brady<br />

Counsel for the Defence For Dragoljub Kunarac: Slaviša Prodanović and Dejan Savatić<br />

For Radomir Kovač: Momir Kolesar and Vladimir Rajić<br />

For Zoran Vuković: Goran Jovanović and Jelena Lopičić<br />

Judgement 12 June 2002<br />

RELATED CASES<br />

by geographical area<br />

JANKOVIĆ et al. (<strong>IT</strong>-<strong>96</strong>-23/2) “FOČA”<br />

KARADŽIĆ & MLADIĆ (<strong>IT</strong>-95-5/18) “BOSNIA AND HERZEGOVINA” & “SREBRENICA”<br />

KRAJISNIK (<strong>IT</strong>-00-39 & 40) “BOSNIA AND HERZEGOVINA”<br />

KRNOJELAC (<strong>IT</strong>-97-25) “FOČA”<br />

MILOŠEVIĆ (<strong>IT</strong>-02-54) “KOSOVO, CROATIA & BOSNIA”<br />

PLAVŠIĆ (<strong>IT</strong>-00-39 AND 40/1) “BOSNIA AND HERZEGOVINA”<br />

TODOVIĆ & RAŠEVIĆ (<strong>IT</strong>-97-25/1) “FOČA”<br />

4


CASE INFORMATION SHEET “FOČA” (<strong>IT</strong>-<strong>96</strong>-23 and 23/1) KUNARAC, KOVAČ & VUKOVIĆ<br />

INDICTMENT AND CHARGES<br />

Dragoljub Kunarac, Radomir Kovač and Zoran Vuković were originally named in an indictment confirmed<br />

on 26 June 19<strong>96</strong> with five other co-accused (Dragan Gagović, Dragan Zelenović, Gojko Janković, Janko<br />

Janjić and Radovan Stanković).<br />

Following the death of Dragan Gagović on 30 July 1999, the indictment was withdrawn against him. An<br />

amended indictment was confirmed against Gojko Janković, Dragan Zelenović, Janko Janjić, Zoran<br />

Vuković and Radovan Stanković on 7 October 1999. Gojko Janković was transferred to the ICTY on 14<br />

March 2005 and Janko Janjić is deceased. Radovan Stanković was arrested on 9 July 2002 and transferred<br />

to the Tribunal the next day. On 3 March 2003, the Prosecution filed a separate indictment against<br />

Radovan Stanković. Dragan Zelenović was transferred to the ICTY on 10 June 2006.<br />

Following the detention of Zoran Vuković on 23 December 1999, a redacted indictment was confirmed on<br />

16 February 2000 (<strong>IT</strong>-<strong>96</strong>-23/1). Kunarac, Kovač and Vuković stood trial jointly under the combined case<br />

number <strong>IT</strong>-<strong>96</strong>-23 and <strong>IT</strong>-<strong>96</strong>-23/1.<br />

Dragoljub Kunarac was charged on the basis of individual criminal responsibility (Article 7(1) of the<br />

Statute of the Tribunal) and superior criminal responsibility (Article 7(3)), with:<br />

• Torture, rape and enslavement (crimes against humanity, Article 5),<br />

• Torture, rape and outrages upon personal dignity (violations of the laws or customs of war, Article 3).<br />

Radomir Kovač was charged on the basis of individual criminal responsibility with:<br />

• Rape and outrages upon personal dignity (violations of the laws or customs of war, Article 3),<br />

• Enslavement and rape (crimes against humanity, Article 5).<br />

Zoran Vuković was charged on the basis of individual criminal responsibility with:<br />

• Torture and rape (violations of the laws or customs of war, Article 3 and crimes against humanity,<br />

Article 5).<br />

THE TRIAL<br />

The trial of Kunarac, Kovač and Vuković commenced on 20 March 2000 before Trial Chamber II (Judge<br />

Mumba (presiding), Judge Hunt and Judge Pocar). The closing arguments took place on 20 November 2000<br />

for the Prosecution, and on 21 and <strong>22</strong> November 2000 for the Defence.<br />

RULE 98 bis PROCEEDINGS<br />

After the Prosecution concludes the presentation of its evidence, the Defence can ask for the dismissal of<br />

the case, if it believes that the presented evidence was insufficient to prove the charges. If the Trial<br />

Chamber believes that the Prosecution has not presented sufficient evidence, it can dismiss the case or<br />

certain charges and enter a judgement of acquittal before the beginning of the presentation of defence<br />

evidence.<br />

In accordance with Rule 98 bis, on 20 June 2000, Kunarac, Kovač and Vuković filed a joint motion for a<br />

judgement of acquittal on certain counts charged in the indictments against them. On 3 July 2000, the<br />

Trial Chamber entered a decision of acquittal in favour of Kunarac on count 13 of the third amended<br />

indictment, confirmed on 1 December 1999, and held that Vuković had no case to answer in relation to<br />

the allegations made by Witness FWS-48 in support of counts 33, 34, 35 and 36 of the redacted<br />

indictment, filed on 21 February 2000. (Vuković still faced charges with regard to the two other victims<br />

under these counts). All remaining counts stood.<br />

TRIAL CHAMBER JUDGEMENT<br />

The three accused participated in a campaign by Bosnian Serb forces in the wider area of the municipality<br />

of Foča, south eastern Bosnia, from early 1992 up to about mid 1993. The campaign was part of an armed<br />

conflict between the Serb and Muslim forces in the wider region of Foča, which existed at all times<br />

material to the indictments against the accused.<br />

5


CASE INFORMATION SHEET “FOČA” (<strong>IT</strong>-<strong>96</strong>-23 and 23/1) KUNARAC, KOVAČ & VUKOVIĆ<br />

One purpose of the campaign was, among others, to cleanse the Foča area of Muslims; to that end the<br />

campaign was successful. Even the town’s name was cleansed.<br />

One target of that campaign, apart from the Muslim armed forces, were Muslim civilians, and in this case,<br />

particularly Muslim women.<br />

The method employed was mostly expulsion through terror. On a general level, the terror expressed itself<br />

in the violent destruction of the religious symbols of the Muslims. All mosques in Foča were blown up and<br />

the ruins razed to the ground.<br />

Civilian Muslim men and women were rounded up in the villages surrounding Foča and even as far as the<br />

neighbouring municipalities of Kalinovik and Gacko. The men were separated from the women and<br />

children.<br />

The men often had to suffer long periods of detention in the Foča KP Dom prison. Detention was without<br />

justification. Some were severely mistreated when they were captured. Some were killed on the spot,<br />

often in the presence or within earshot of their families.<br />

The women and children from the Foča region were taken to collection points, such as Buk Bijela, a<br />

settlement south of Foča. From there, they were transferred by bus to Foča High School, where they were<br />

detained. Some of them were later taken to other places in and around Foča, such as Partizan Sports Hall<br />

and to private houses in Miljevina and Trnovača. There they met women and girls from the other two<br />

municipalities.<br />

What the evidence showed was that the rapes were used by members of the Bosnian Serb armed forces as<br />

an instrument of terror. An instrument they were given free rein to apply whenever and against<br />

whomsoever they wished.<br />

What the evidence showed was that it was possible for the Serb forces to set up and maintain a detention<br />

centre for scores of Muslim women such as Partizan Sports Hall, next to the municipal police building in<br />

Foča, from which women and young girls were taken away on a regular basis to other locations to be<br />

raped.<br />

What the evidence demonstrated was that the authorities who were meant to protect the victims, such as<br />

the local police which had been taken over by the Serbs, turned a blind eye to their suffering. Instead,<br />

they helped guard the women, and even joined in their maltreatment when approached by them for help<br />

against their oppressors. What the evidence showed was Muslim women and girls, mothers and daughters<br />

together, robbed of the last vestiges of human dignity; women and girls treated like chattels, pieces of<br />

property at the arbitrary disposal of the Serb occupation forces, and more specifically, at the beck and<br />

call of the three accused.<br />

On <strong>22</strong> February 2001, the Trial Chamber rendered its judgement, convicting the accused as follows:<br />

Dragoljub Kunarac, on the basis of individual criminal responsibility (Article 7(1) of the Statute of the<br />

Tribunal) with:<br />

• Torture, rape and enslavement (crimes against humanity, Article 5)<br />

• Torture and rape (violations of the laws or customs of war, Article 3)<br />

Sentence: 28 years’ imprisonment.<br />

Radomir Kovač, on the basis of individual criminal responsibility with:<br />

• Rape and outrages upon personal dignity (violations of the laws or customs of war, Article 3)<br />

• Enslavement and rape (crimes against humanity, Article 5)<br />

Sentence: 20 years’ imprisonment.<br />

Zoran Vuković, on the basis of individual criminal responsibility with:<br />

• Torture and rape (violations of the laws or customs of war, Article 3 and crimes against humanity,<br />

Article 5)<br />

6


CASE INFORMATION SHEET “FOČA” (<strong>IT</strong>-<strong>96</strong>-23 and 23/1) KUNARAC, KOVAČ & VUKOVIĆ<br />

Sentence: 12 years’ imprisonment.<br />

APPEALS CHAMBER JUDGEMENT<br />

On 6 March 2001, Radomir Kovač and Zoran Vuković filed a notice of appeal against the Trial Chamber<br />

judgement and sentence. On 7 March 2001, Dragoljub Kunarac did so as well.<br />

The Appellants presented several grounds of appeal and alleged errors by the Trial Chamber with respect<br />

to various legal issues. The Appeals Chamber rendered its judgement on 12 June 2002 affirming the<br />

sentences handed down by Trial Chamber II on <strong>22</strong> February 2001.<br />

On 28 November 2002, Radomir Kovač and Zoran Vuković were transferred to Norway to serve their<br />

sentences. On 12 December 2002, Dragoljub Kunarac was transferred to Germany to serve his sentence.<br />

Document prepared by the Communications Service. All ICTY key documents are available on: www.un.org/icty<br />

International Criminal Tribunal for the former Yugoslavia. Churchillplein 1, 2517 JW The Hague, Netherlands.<br />

7

Hooray! Your file is uploaded and ready to be published.

Saved successfully!

Ooh no, something went wrong!